Happy Tuesday, GoldBuzzers!

If you checked your screen on Monday and winced, you weren't alone. Gold had one of its worst days since June, silver fell harder, and the trigger was something that's normally good for both.

Today's issue walks through why the usual playbook broke, what this week's data needs to show, and why the loudest explanation for Monday only covers part of it.

Ok. Let’s get into it. ⬇️

The week opened with a thud. Gold dropped close to four percent on Monday, settling at $4,135 an ounce for its weakest finish in seven weeks, and silver fell harder still, down more than four percent to under $61.

President Trump rejected Iran's latest proposal to reopen the Strait of Hormuz, and Brent crude climbed back toward $106 a barrel. Expensive oil feeds straight into inflation, which is exactly what the Federal Reserve is trying to squash. Having delivered its first rate hike since 2023 earlier this month, the Fed is now widely expected to follow up - markets put the odds of another increase in October at roughly 70 percent.

That kept the 10-year Treasury yield near 5.2 percent, close to its highest level in 19 years, and firmed up the dollar. Gold and silver don't pay interest, so when bonds offer returns like that, some money drifts toward bonds instead. The next tests arrive fast: Wednesday brings the PCE inflation report (the Fed's preferred measure) and Friday brings the September jobs numbers.

Hot readings would strengthen the case for more hikes and keep the metals under pressure, but cooler ones would give them room to breathe.

No doubt about it - Monday was rough. Spot gold slid through $4,200 and finished near $4,135, its lowest level since early August and one of its worst days since June. Silver fared worse, dropping from Friday's $64.30 to under $61. Miners took the biggest hit, with the main gold and silver mining index down around five percent. Put Monday's price on all the gold ever mined and roughly $1 trillion of paper value disappeared in a single session.

Those are the raw numbers. The more useful question is what did the damage, because the easy explanation doesn't hold up.

It wasn't really oil

The morning headlines all blamed crude. Brent jumped toward $109 in early Asian trading after Washington rejected Tehran's latest proposal to reopen the Strait of Hormuz, and that's when gold first broke lower. But oil gave nearly all of it back and closed up less than one percent, around $105. Gold never recovered with it. If oil had been the real driver, it would have.

But the pressure that stuck came from the bond market, and it had been building for a week. The 10-year Treasury yield climbed above 5.2 percent, its highest since 2007. The 30-year is around 5.5 percent, last seen in 2004. The dollar hit a two-month high. The odds of another rate hike in October, on top of the quarter-point move the Fed made earlier this month to a range of 3.75 to 4 percent, now sit at about 70 percent.

That matters because gold and silver don't pay you anything to hold them. When the safe, boring alternative starts paying more than five percent, some investors sell the metal and buy the bond. Instead of the usual "trouble in the Middle East, buy gold" reaction, Monday traded as "rates are going higher, sell whatever doesn't pay."

The price levels have flipped too. $4,200 had been acting as a floor for gold. Now it's the first ceiling. If gold can't climb back above it, $4,150 and $4,100 stay in play. For silver the line was $62. Lose that cleanly and $60 is the next number people will argue about.

A big week for data

This week should tell us whether Monday was a one-day shakeout or the start of something longer. Job openings data lands today, the Fed's preferred inflation gauge (PCE) comes Wednesday, a manufacturing survey on Thursday and the monthly jobs report Friday. Soft numbers would pull yields back and give metals some breathing room. A hot inflation print or a strong jobs number will keep the pressure on.

The other half of the story

Nobody's arguing about the first part: yields went up, metals went down, and that's what happens when the alternative starts paying again.

The second part is the one worth arguing about. Peter Schiff made the case on Monday night, and it's worth taking seriously. The rate hikes probably won't be enough to break inflation, but they will slow the economy and widen the budget deficit, with unemployment rising along the way. If inflation then runs faster than the Fed's policy rate, real interest rates (the rate you actually earn after inflation) fall. Historically, that's the environment gold likes best.

None of this means gold bounces immediately, but it does mean the bond market can overrule gold for a week or even a quarter without changing the big picture. The US is still running a deficit near $1.9 trillion with debt above 100 percent of GDP, and the interest bill on that debt can no longer be ignored. A Fed that raises rates into that mix can tighten financial conditions and still leave the Treasury with a much bigger bill to refinance.

Bond yields can rise and gold can still do well if the rise is a symptom of inflation that policy can't fully contain. The 1970s comparison is imperfect, they always are, but the mechanism is one this newsletter keeps coming back to: gold doesn't need rates to fall right away, it just needs real rates to stop rising.

What to make of Monday’s Action

Don't mistake a $1 trillion paper loss for a change in who's actually buying. Futures and ETF holders sold because bonds paid more that day. Central banks and Asian buyers have shrugged off days like this before. Miners will look worse than the metal until yields settle down. That's the leverage in mining shares, and it cuts both ways.

The practical test is simple. If gold can't reclaim $4,200 on this week's data, the correction has further to run and silver will stay the more volatile of the two. If yields ease on cooler inflation numbers, Monday will start to look like the bond market getting a full quarter's worth of repricing done in one afternoon.

That's why this week's data matters more than Monday's close. If it comes in hot, the yield argument keeps winning for now. If it comes in soft, the deficit argument gets its first hearing, and it's the one that decides where gold goes from here.

That’s all for this Tuesday, folks. I’ll see you on Thursday.

Before you go, please take a moment to rate today’s newsletter and tell us how we did.

Rick Adams
Founder, GoldBuzz
rick@goldbuzz.com