Happy Thursday, GoldBuzzers!

There’s no hiding the fact that silver's chart isn’t looking pretty. Still down almost 40% from January's $121 peak. Meanwhile, China spent Q1 doing something the headlines have mostly ignored.

Today's Real Talk is about what they did, and why the chart is the wrong place to be looking right now.

Let’s get into it. ⬇️

Gold clawed back above $4,500 on Wednesday after bottoming near a two-month low of $4,474 the session before, while silver firmed above $75. The bounce came on the back of real developments out of the Persian Gulf, where three supertankers carrying a combined six million barrels of crude exited the Strait of Hormuz for the first time in weeks - a sign that the energy chokehold is loosening.

President Trump added fuel, stating a deal with Iran was in its "final stages." Oil prices dropped on the news, and with them, some of the inflation pressure that has been hammering metals over the past two weeks. But the relief was short-lived.

FOMC minutes from the April 28-29 meeting, released Wednesday afternoon, showed a majority of policymakers believe rate hikes may be needed this year if inflation stays above 2%. Multiple members had already dissented against the easing bias at the last rate hold, and the minutes confirmed that the door to tightening is wide open. Markets are currently split roughly 50/50 on whether a hike lands by December.

Worth noting: these were the last minutes under outgoing Chair Powell, making the June meeting under incoming Chair Warsh the one to watch. For now, gold remains trapped between two opposing forces - falling energy risk pulling it up, and a hawkish Fed pushing it down.

As silver sits nearly 40% off from its January 29 peak of $121.08, the headlines all blame the same culprits: stronger dollar, hawkish Fed talk and Middle East risk premiums on oil. Fair enough on the macro. What's harder to square is what China spent the past four months doing.

Two things happened in parallel. The first is a policy shift most Western news desks barely covered. On January 1, Beijing replaced its 25-year-old silver export quota system with a strict licensing regime. Silver is now classified as a strategic material, sitting on the same regulatory shelf as rare earths and antimony.

Only 44 firms (mostly state-owned) are cleared to export through 2027. Each shipment needs case-by-case approval, with review windows reportedly running up to 45 days. To qualify, refiners need 80 tonnes of annual capacity and a verified export history from 2022 to 2024. Smaller exporters are out.

The second thing was buying. Lots of it.

China imported 836 tonnes of silver in March alone, per Chinese Customs data. That's 173% above the 10-year March average and the highest single-month figure on record. Q1 came in around 1,626 tonnes, also a record. To put that in context: China was a net exporter of roughly 5,100 tonnes in 2025. It has flipped to aggressive net importer inside a single quarter.

The buying is driven by two unrelated forces hitting at the same time. Industrial users front-loaded purchases ahead of the April 1 expiry of an export tax rebate on solar panels. And Chinese retail investors, priced out of gold near $5,500, are buying physical silver bars as a substitute. Chinese spot silver has been trading at premiums of 12-17% over international benchmarks, which has pulled metal east from Western vaults.

This isn't isolated. The People's Bank of China just extended its gold-buying streak to 18 consecutive months in April. Official holdings sit at 2,322 tonnes.

Over the same window, China cut its US Treasury holdings to $652 billion as of March, the lowest level since September 2008. That's an 18-year low. Hard to read that as anything other than a deliberate rotation out of paper and into metal.

Worth flagging the obvious tension though: physical demand and the spot price can decouple for longer than people expect. China's record imports happened while silver fell 40% from its January high. Spot is set in COMEX and LBMA futures, where macro flows and leveraged positioning dominate. Chinese physical buying doesn't set the global price. It sets a floor.

Spot can ignore fundamentals for a quarter. It rarely ignores them for a cycle. Eventually the physical market reasserts itself, and the question becomes whether you're positioned before or after that happens.

That floor matters when the supply backdrop is what it is. The global silver market is in its sixth straight year of deficit. Industrial demand (solar, EVs, electronics, AI infrastructure) now accounts for over half of total consumption. COMEX registered inventories are down nearly 70% from 2020 levels. LBMA holdings are off about 40%. Layer China's export choke on top of that and the medium-term math gets harder for bears to defend.

The downside risks are worth naming, but they're narrower than they look. As I outlined last Sunday, Silver's spot price is significantly more volatile than gold by a wide margin, and macro alone (a hawkish Fed, dollar strength, the oil price) can push it lower for stretches that test conviction. That's a timing problem, not a thesis problem. The thesis only breaks if China reverses the export regime, primary mine supply surges meaningfully, or industrial substitution kicks in at scale. Nothing in the data points that way. The rotation pattern we just walked through is the behaviour of a country digging into hard assets, not preparing to reverse course.

The story moves on the next round of import data. If China's April and May numbers hold anywhere near March's record, the supply squeeze gets a lot harder to argue against. If they drop back to normal, March was mostly solar buyers front-running the tax deadline and we'll need more time to see. I'll be watching either way.

The squeeze isn't visible on the price chart yet. The physical flows say it's already underway.

That’s all for this Thursday, folks. See you on Sunday.

Before you go, please take a moment to rate today’s newsletter and tell us how we did.

Rick Adams
Founder, GoldBuzz
rick@goldbuzz.com