Happy Thursday, GoldBuzzers!

Yesterday was the kind of day that makes people check their portfolio before they’ve had coffee. The US inflation report came in hot, gold slid, and silver slid a lot further.

In today’s Real Talk, I’ve ranked the day against every other down day of this bull market, because the answer for gold and the answer for silver turned out to be quite different..

And many thanks to everyone who sent feedback and good wishes after the launch of our sister site, GoldPrice.Live on Tuesday morning. Those of us working on it are delighted so many of you have already started to make it part of your daily routine.

Ok. Let’s get into it. ⬇️

Live prices and this morning’s gold and silver commentary at goldprice.live

Gold slid to $4,100 on Wednesday and silver took the harder hit, dropping six percent and closing under $56, after September’s US inflation report came in hotter than expected.

Consumer prices rose 3.7 percent over the year, above the 3.6 percent forecast, with a 0.6 percent monthly jump driven mostly by surging gasoline prices. Core inflation beat expectations too, at 2.6 percent annually. That combination sent the dollar to its highest level since April 2025 and pushed Treasury yields higher - a rough pairing for metals that don’t pay interest.

Markets now put the odds of a Fed rate rise at the October meeting at roughly a coin flip, up from about one-in-five before the report, and a December increase is seen as all but certain.

Days like this are what the consolidation phase looks like: noisy, uncomfortable, and entirely normal for a bull market with years left to run.

Wednesday felt brutal if you were watching the screen. Gold dropped the moment the inflation numbers came out, silver fell twice as hard, and within an hour X was once again full of posts about hundreds of billions of dollars wiped off the gold market in minutes.

Let’s look at what actually happened, why it happened, and how it ranks against the other bad days of this bull market. Two of those three answers are more reassuring than the headlines suggest. One isn’t.

What happened

The US inflation report for September came in hot. Prices rose 0.6 percent in a single month, and the annual rate climbed to 3.7 percent from 3.4 percent in August. Economists had expected 3.6. Gasoline did most of the damage, up 9.1 percent in a month, but the core number that strips out food and energy also beat expectations at 2.6 percent.

Markets reacted within minutes. The dollar firmed, Treasury yields rose, and the odds of a Federal Reserve rate increase at its 27-28 October meeting roughly doubled, from about 22 percent to just over 40 percent. The Fed already raised rates once this year, in September, so this isn’t a hypothetical.

Gold closed at $4,105, down 1.3 percent, after touching $4,074 at the low. Silver closed at $55.63, down 6.0 percent, its lowest close since mid-July. The gold-to-silver ratio, which tells you how many ounces of silver buy one ounce of gold, jumped from 70 to 74 in a single session.

Why hot inflation knocked gold down

This is the question I saw asked most on Wednesday, and it’s a fair one. Gold is supposed to protect you from inflation, so why did it fall on an inflation scare?

The answer is that two different clocks are running. Over years, inflation erodes paper money and gold tends to hold its value against it. Over hours, the market isn’t thinking about that at all. It’s thinking about interest rates.

Gold pays no interest. When investors expect the Fed to raise rates, cash and bonds start paying more, and the cost of holding something that pays nothing goes up. At the same time, higher US rates pull money into dollars, and a stronger dollar makes gold more expensive for everyone buying it in other currencies. Hot inflation data triggers both at once, so gold falls on the day even though the longer-term case hasn’t changed.

So when someone says “I thought gold goes up with inflation,” the honest reply is: it does, over the stretch of time that matters. It just doesn’t do it on the afternoon the market decides the Fed is going to act.

The dollar illusion

Now for the headlines. “Hundreds of billions wiped out” sounds like a crash. It isn’t. It’s the arithmetic of a high price multiplied by an enormous market.

Gold lost $56 an ounce on Wednesday. At $4,100 an ounce, that’s 1.3 percent. The same 1.3 percent move in 2019, when gold was around $1,400, would have been $19, and nobody would have noticed. Big dollar numbers follow big prices. They don’t tell you anything about how severe the day was.

Percentages do. So let’s rank it.

Where Wednesday sits in this bull market

I keep a daily record of gold’s closing price back to 1970. Since the breakout in March 2024 there have been 658 trading days. Wednesday’s 1.3 percent drop ranks 75th worst. There have been 38 days this year alone that were worse.

The worst day of the bull market so far was 30 January this year, when gold fell 9.1 percent in a session. Wednesday doesn’t belong in that conversation. It was a normal bad day in a market that has had plenty of them, and both metals are still well below January’s peaks. That’s the consolidation phase, and days like this are part of it.

Silver’s day was different

Silver doesn’t get the same reassurance. A 6 percent drop is the 16th worst day since the breakout, and it took silver back to levels last seen in July.

There are two reasons silver swings harder than gold. The market is far smaller, so the same amount of selling moves the price more. And roughly half of silver demand is industrial, so a rate scare hits it twice: once as a metal that pays no interest, and again as a bet on factories and solar panels that higher rates might slow down. When the driver is interest rates, silver almost always moves further than gold, in both directions.

What the worst days did next

The useful question isn’t whether Wednesday was scary. It’s what a bad day can tell you about the next month.

I pulled the nine worst gold days of this bull market and checked where the price stood 20 trading days later, roughly a month.

Six of the nine were higher a month on, with an average gain of 4.7 percent across all nine. The three that weren’t included 3 March this year, when gold was another 8 percent lower a month later. Push the window out to two or three months and the record is close to a coin flip.

That’s not a reason to despair, and it’s not a reason to pile in either. It’s a reason to stop reading single days as signals. A bad day in a bull market is usually followed by a bounce. It’s not reliably followed by a recovery, and the difference between those two outcomes is where most people lose money chasing headlines.

Which is why I don’t trade on days like Wednesday. I follow rules instead, and know that patience is always rewarded in bull markets.

That’s all for this Thursday, folks. I’ll see you on Sunday.

Before you go, please take a moment to rate today’s newsletter and tell us how we did.

Rick Adams
Founder, GoldBuzz
rick@goldbuzz.com